Skip to content

How Do You Make a Maple Bourbon Old Fashioned?

By Brett Murphy ·

7 min read

A maple bourbon Old Fashioned combines bourbon whiskey, pure maple syrup and aromatic bitters in a simple stirred cocktail served over a large ice cube. The maple syrup replaces the sugar or simple syrup used in many traditional Old Fashioned recipes, introducing a subtle woody sweetness that complements the bourbon. An orange twist provides a fragrant finishing touch. The secret is to use maple syrup sparingly so the drink remains balanced rather than tasting like a sweet dessert beverage.

Recipe at a Glance

Yield: one cocktail. Preparation time: approximately five minutes. Equipment: mixing glass, bar spoon, jigger, cocktail strainer and rocks glass. Serve over fresh ice. This recipe is intended for adults of legal drinking age.

Ingredients for a Maple Bourbon Old Fashioned

Measure 1½ ounces bourbon whiskey, ¼ ounce pure maple syrup and 2 dashes aromatic bitters. You will also need fresh ice for stirring and serving, plus a strip of orange peel for garnish. A cocktail cherry is optional. A quarter ounce of syrup is equivalent to one and a half teaspoons. If you prefer a drier drink, begin with one teaspoon of maple syrup. Choose a standard-strength bourbon and check the label for the actual alcoholic strength.

Choosing the Bourbon

Bourbon is particularly compatible with maple syrup because many examples have flavor notes associated with vanilla, caramel, toasted oak and baking spices. You do not need an expensive bottle for this recipe. A familiar bourbon with a pleasant aroma and a balanced finish is sufficient. Different bourbons can emphasize different aspects of the grain and barrel character, so the same cocktail may taste slightly different depending on the bottle. Rye whiskey can be substituted for a spicier variation, although that changes the characteristic bourbon base.

Choosing Pure Maple Syrup

Pure maple syrup provides a different flavor from ordinary pancake syrup, which may be made primarily with other sweeteners and artificial maple flavoring. Look for a product labeled pure maple syrup. Amber syrup with a rich taste is a convenient starting point, while dark syrup with a robust taste creates a more prominent maple aroma. Golden syrup with a delicate taste provides a subtler result. Because syrup is concentrated, a small amount is generally sufficient. Follow the storage directions on the label; opened pure maple syrup is typically kept refrigerated. Do not assume that a bottle with visible mold is safe to use.

Why Aromatic Bitters Are Important

Aromatic bitters contribute concentrated botanical flavors that balance the sweetness of maple syrup and add complexity to the bourbon. Two dashes provide a useful starting point, though dash sizes vary according to the bottle. If you use orange bitters instead, the drink will have a more citrus-forward character. A mixture of one dash aromatic bitters and one dash orange bitters offers another variation. Avoid adding several different bitters at once until you are familiar with their flavor, since the recipe contains only a few ingredients and each addition is noticeable.

Step 1: Prepare the Glass and Garnish

Choose a sturdy rocks glass with room for a large ice cube and the finished cocktail. Chill the glass briefly in the refrigerator if desired. Wash an orange under running water and cut a thin strip of peel using a vegetable peeler or small knife. Try to avoid removing too much bitter white pith. Set the peel aside on a clean plate. Prepare a large fresh ice cube or several ordinary cubes for the serving glass.

Step 2: Measure and Mix the Ingredients

Pour the bourbon into a clean mixing glass. Add the measured maple syrup and aromatic bitters. Stir briefly before adding ice so the syrup begins to disperse throughout the whiskey. Use a jigger or measuring spoons rather than estimating the quantities. Pure maple syrup has a thicker consistency than many simple syrups, so taking a moment to mix it thoroughly helps prevent a concentrated layer of sweetness at the bottom of the glass.

Step 3: Stir With Ice

Fill the mixing glass with firm ice cubes and stir steadily for approximately twenty to thirty seconds. The cold ice lowers the temperature of the mixture while adding a modest amount of water through melting. This dilution is an important part of the cocktail rather than an unwanted side effect. It helps the whiskey, maple and bitters come together. The exact amount of stirring needed varies with the ice, mixing vessel and starting temperature of the ingredients. If the drink seems overly concentrated, a little additional stirring or a small amount of chilled water can help.

Step 4: Strain Into the Rocks Glass

Place fresh ice in the prepared serving glass and strain the chilled cocktail over it. A large cube generally melts more slowly than a handful of small cubes because it has less surface area relative to its volume. However, ordinary freezer ice is perfectly adequate. Use clean, fresh ice without noticeable freezer odors. Avoid pouring all the partly melted mixing ice into the serving glass because it can continue diluting the cocktail more quickly.

Step 5: Garnish With Orange Peel

Hold the orange peel over the glass with the colored side facing the drink and gently squeeze or twist it to release its fragrant oils. Place the peel in the glass or rest it against the ice. An optional cocktail cherry adds a different flavor and appearance, but the recipe does not require one. Serve promptly while the cocktail is chilled. There is no need to muddle a large piece of orange or add orange juice, since the expressed peel supplies the intended citrus aroma without significantly changing the drink’s sweetness.

How to Balance the Maple Flavor

The maple syrup should complement the whiskey rather than conceal it. If the cocktail tastes too sweet, use a smaller measure of syrup next time or add a little chilled water. If it seems too dry, stir in a small additional amount of maple syrup. Taste with a clean spoon between adjustments. Different grades of syrup may have noticeably different flavor intensity even when their sweetness is similar. Avoid correcting an overly sweet cocktail by adding more bourbon. A careful adjustment to the sweetener is usually more effective.

How to Make Four Servings

Combine six ounces bourbon, one ounce pure maple syrup and eight dashes aromatic bitters in a clean mixing vessel. Stir to distribute the syrup. Divide into four equal portions and stir each portion with fresh ice before straining into a rocks glass. Prepare the orange peels separately so they retain their aroma. If mixing the undiluted ingredients ahead of time, keep them in a clean covered, clearly labeled container in the refrigerator and use them the same day for best quality. Provide water and alcohol-free refreshments alongside the cocktails.

Easy Flavor Variations

For a maple orange Old Fashioned, substitute orange bitters for one of the dashes of aromatic bitters. For a spiced variation, use a cinnamon stick as a garnish rather than adding a large amount of ground cinnamon. A maple rye Old Fashioned uses rye whiskey in place of bourbon and has a different grain character. For a lighter version, use less bourbon and add chilled water to preserve the approximate serving volume.

Alcohol-Free Maple Old Fashioned Alternative

Combine one and a half ounces chilled unsweetened black tea or an alcohol-free whiskey-style beverage, one teaspoon pure maple syrup and a few drops of alcohol-free aromatic flavoring. Stir with ice and strain over a fresh cube, then garnish with orange peel. Check the labels if complete avoidance of alcohol is necessary. The alcoholic recipe contains approximately one US standard drink when made with bourbon at 40 percent alcohol by volume. Higher-proof bourbon changes the amount. Never drive after drinking.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use honey instead of maple syrup?

Yes, although it creates a different flavor. Thin the honey with a little warm water and cool it before mixing.

Should I shake a maple Old Fashioned?

Stirring is preferred because this cocktail contains no juice, cream or other ingredients that require vigorous shaking.

Can I use pancake syrup?

Pure maple syrup is recommended for its distinctive flavor. Other syrups can significantly change the result.

Final Tips

Measure the maple syrup, stir thoroughly with ice and finish with fresh orange peel. Keep the sweetness subtle so the bourbon and bitters remain noticeable.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use honey instead of maple syrup?

Yes, although it creates a different flavor. Thin the honey with a little warm water and cool it before mixing.

Should I shake a maple Old Fashioned?

Stirring is preferred because this cocktail contains no juice, cream or other ingredients that require vigorous shaking.

Can I use pancake syrup?

Pure maple syrup is recommended for its distinctive flavor. Other syrups can significantly change the result.

Leave a Reply